Choosing a Nursing Home

For consumer based information about NYC nursing homes, call

FRIA's Helpline

Nursing Home Checklist

Culture Change

Conscience Policies

There is no way to choose an ideal home or to feel confident that a relative will receive wonderful care. Although some families experience problem-free stays, problems arise at all homes. All New York homes are understaffed. Mistakes are bound to happen in large institutions that employ large staffs in three shifts that care for very sick people.

Often, homes are better at some things than others. Different homes offer quite different feelings and surroundings.


To Choose a Nursing Home

Network within your community. Citizen advocacy groups like FRIA are good resources as are churches, special diseases groups like the Alzheimer’s Association chapters, local long-term care ombudsman programs and area offices for the aging.

Try to connect with other families who have nursing home experience.

Visit several homes. Ask to see floors not on the prearranged tour, stay through at least one meal and talk to residents and visitors as well as staff.


To read FRIA’s checklist for visits to prospective homes, refer to the link above.

The following information should help you make the best choice for your family:


Eliminate sub-standard homes

Recognize them by visiting, networking within your community (remember FRIA’s helpline), and checking state and federal websites giving information about inspection survey results and quality of care indicators.

For more information about inspection survey results, click here.  For more information about quality measures, click here.



Meet your relative’s care needs

For someone bed bound, needing highly skilled care and with limited ability to interact socially, top nursing standards are the first concern even if the home has few activities and feels very hospital-like. A model Alzheimer’s unit will mean little to someone whose needs stem from a physical disability. For someone mentally alert but physically dependent, activities and socially active peers are key.

Families with cultural or language concerns may face especially hard choices. Some choose to meet medical needs first and advocate for cultural responsiveness after placement. Some homes have specialized language, diet and activity resources. A few homes offer a welcoming atmosphere to gay and lesbian residents.



To read “What Families Need to Know and Do: Nursing Home Placement When There are Cultural and Language Concerns”, click here.


Focus on your relative’s preferences, not yours

An on-site chapel or kosher-style food may be a deciding factor. Some people find a structured, formal atmosphere comforting. Others prefer a home that appears freer, allowing Alzheimer’s residents to choose their own clothing and wander freely within a monitored space.

If your relative has strong feelings about end-of-life care, you should check which homes have religious or morally based policies that limit resident options.

To read “Conscience Policies in Nursing Homes” and identify New York City homes with conscience policies, click here.



Choose a place convenient to likely visitors and make visits frequent and unpredictable.

Residents get better care when outsiders visit regularly, monitor their condition and work to resolve any problems that arise. Most families chose homes close to visiting relatives even if others, further away, appear to have somewhat higher care standards.



If possible, choose a home that will be responsive to your concerns.

Some families choose to settle for lower standards in some areas in order to obtain a greater responsiveness to residents’ every day preferences and idiosyncrasies and a willingness to investigate and correct problems promptly.

The presence of many visiting families is usually a sign of “better than average” conditions and responsiveness. It is also a protection and tool for addressing problems and for enhancing quality of life for all residents. Visiting families in well-run homes should be willing to speak to prospective visiting families about the home’s good and bad points.



Short-term rehab in nursing homes usually ends with return home. If long-term care is needed after the short-term rehab (and Medicare) ends, the home cannot legally insist on a move to another nursing home, although many try.


Government Resources

FRIA’s Quality Measures fact sheet discusses how to find and use information concerning nursing home quality measures that are collected by government agencies that oversee nursing homes.


Other Resources

FRIA’s helpline will share the knowledge we have about individual nursing homes in New York City.

FRIA’s book Eldercare in New York discusses the selection and placement process as well as Medicare and Medicaid rules and alternatives to nursing home care in New York.

©2003FRIA